Opinion

Who really benefits from school consolidation?

To the editor:

It has been five years since Citizens Organization for Rural Education embarked on its mission to help sustain local education in Danforth, Weston and the surrounding area of rural eastern Maine. Initial research found that local education is the single largest contributor to whole community well-being in rural economies.  

In 2017, CORE engaged Sunrise County Economic Council to undertake an economic impact analysis for Danforth and the surrounding area should all or part of the East Grand School close. The results were dire.

East Grand School (RSU 84 Danforth/Weston) in its entirety contributes more than $3 million and 43 jobs to the Danforth-Weston economy; the high school portion alone amounts to nearly $1 million and 13 jobs. Results were published in a report titled, “Economic Impact Study — Danforth, Maine.” It is available on the SCEC website.

Responsible citizenry expects meaningful and financially sustainable local education. East Grand School has made great strides to adapt to small class size and introduce active, place-based learning while holding costs in check. Just this year, the school was recognized as one of two statewide Maine Association Middle Level Educators Exemplary Practice Award winners, and received National recognition as a top five finalist for State Educational Technology Directors Association Student Voices Award. Teachers and students will be showcasing their project at a ceremony in Washington, D.C., in November. 

An article titled “Strategies to Revitalize Rural America” by the Center for Rural Affairs in Nebraska, may have said it best: “State policymakers should not blindly force school consolidation that undermines both education and communities. Small schools can provide the best educational outcome for most children, and efficiency gains of consolidation often disappear when construction and transportation costs are counted. [Confirmed as the most likely outcome for consolidation at East Grand]. A much better course is to seek opportunities for communities to work together in ways to help them keep and strengthen their schools while holding the line on cost.” 

The 2017 National Forum to Advance Rural Education stated “Schools matter to the economic, social and cultural vitality of a rural community; they are places where relationships are sustained, traditions are preserved and values are learned.”

CORE believes such outcomes and opportunities as stated above represent the correct vision and direction for local education. 

Elbridge Cleaves
President of Citizens Organization for Rural Education
Danforth

Get the Rest of the Story

Thank you for reading your 4 free articles this month. To continue reading, and support local, rural journalism, please subscribe.