To the editor:
If you plan to attend the Natural Resources Council of Maine (NRCM) forum on wind power in Houlton tomorrow night, you would be wise to learn something on your own about inland industrial wind “farms” in advance. Last February, we went to a similar “forum” put on by NRCM in Lincoln prior to the vote by the powers-that-be in Lincoln on First Wind’s proposed Rollins wind “farm.” It was a whitewash, with all panel members either profitting from Big Wind or turning a blind eye to the many problems such industrialization poses for residents of rural Maine. We were asked to write our questions on paper which were then “sorted” by a NRCM employee. Only upon insistance of the audience members were all questions read out, even though there was plenty of time. Not surprisingly, it turned out that the questions not originally read for the panel to answer were ones challenging or asking for more in-depth data.
One of the biggest reasons given for wind power is that it will help mitigate the global warming problem by reducing the amount of CO2 released into the atmosphere. This is a myth according to the Green Party of Maine, whose statement opposing inland industrial wind “farms” can be read on the Friends of Lincoln Lakes Web site. Because wind charts show that NE Maine has only marginal to fair wind velocity, a great deal of back-up power is needed to keep the grid stable. The back-up of choice is natural gas turbines which must be built in tandem with wind “farms.” Our research uncovered a study by the Electrical Supply Board of Ireland which concluded in 2004 that “operating gas turbines by ramping up and down generates more CO2 per kWh of electrical generation than if the gas turbines were operated on normal planned load … As the level of wind capacity increases, the CO2 emissions actually increase as a direct result of having to cope with the variations of wind power output.”
Add to this, the fact that after clear-cutting for wind tower and transmission line placement plus blasting to bedrock, the foundations for the wind towers require hundreds of tons of concrete. For every one ton of concrete manufactured, one ton of CO2 is released into the air. Overall, big wind installations operating in inland marginal wind areas are not “green” — similar to the ethanol-from-corn debacle.
Transmission line problems abound for wind energy produced in inland Maine to reach the Boston market, and the “fixes” are very costly. Aroostook Wind pulled out temporarily from the County about six months ago (Bangor Daily News, 1/15/09, “If wind doesn’t blow, blackouts roll: Technical glitches could destabilize New England electric power grid.”) T. Boone Pickens has just nixed his plan for a huge wind “farm” in Texas because of transmission line problems. Will the wind power from First Wind’s numerous industrial wind sites “bump” the power generated by present and future (i.e. Millinockett) bio-mass plants off the current transmission lines with their inadequate capacity?
We have Rep. Roger Sherman and Houlton Water Company’s John Clark to thank for the recent passage of a bill in the state legislature that forbids having local rate-payers footing the bill for new transmission lines needed only for sale of wind energy to New England.
Then there are the health concerns associated with 400-foot-plus tall, 1.5 MW wind towers. At its monthly meeting of 3/3/09, the medical staff of Northern Maine Medical Center stated: “We echo the concerns of the Medical Staff of Rumford Commuity Hospital as regards an increasing body of literature and reports from Canada, the USA and particularly from Europe suggesting that deployment of industrial wind facilities in close proximity to places where people live, work or attend schools result in negative health effects, including especially sleep deprivation and stress. These effects arise not only from audible noise frequencies but also persistent inaudible low frequency waves of a cyclical nature which are felt, not heard. There are a growing number of scientific observations and studies suggesting that people living up to two miles away from these industrial wind farms may be affected.” Hunters and those depending on “sports” or other tourists also need to be alerted to the absence of wildlife.
According to U.S. Congressman Eric Massa (D-NY) on 4/25/09 in a radio interview: “… hunters are coming up and telling me that there’s no wildlife anywhere within distance, and I’m talking three to four miles, of any of their wind turbines because they emit low-frequency vibrations that drive the deer away.” Of course, predators cannot be heard either.
Neither DEP or LURC commissioners have ever required big wind firms to study low-frequency waves (dBC) when submitting applications for permits. The 45 dBA (audible noise) top level which used to be the restriction for big wind farms has now been exceeded at Mars HIll and measured inside homes there as high as 52 dBA. DEP is allowing this without a slap on the wrist to First Wind. Google Dr. Nina Pierpont on the ill effects of Wind Turbine Syndrome. Wind Watch is another good resource for information about big wind.
To get permitting from Maine regulatory agencies and tax breaks from small towns, Massachusetts-based First Wind (developer of Mars Hill, Stetson I, Stetson II and Rollins — the latter two now on appeal by residents — and many others) promises many goodies to benefit the local area. However, a month after the grand opening of Stetson I in Danforth with Gov. Baldacci attending, First Wind put Stetson I up for sale. According to “Power Finance and Risk” on February 27, 2009: “Newton, Mass.-based First Wind has put its 57 MW Stetson wind project in Danforth, Maine up for sale. Credit Suisse is running the deal.” What happens to all the promises, let alone contracts, when First Wind gets out of Dodge?
Harrison and Marilyn Roper
Houlton







