By Rep. Richard Cleary
(D-Houlton)
It is a different experience being a second-term legislator. Again I am serving on the Business, Research and Economic Development (BRED) Committee, and I have a better understanding of the legislative and committee processes, and I have learned from past successes and failures.
The Legislature came close to passing a comprehensive tax reform package during the first session of the 123rd Legislature, only to have is passage blocked by special interests. There were some problems with that tax reform package, but having been through the process once, I was able to look back during this year’s tax reform debate and see the past bill’s strengths and weaknesses.
I am proud to say that we were able to pass legislation that will lower the top income tax rate for most Mainers from 8.5 to 6.5 percent – a significant reduction. Further, additional new tax credits will drop that rate much further for most filers – including individuals and families in our area. This substantial reduction comes at a time when many other states are increasing taxes to balance their budgets. They are going for the quick fix in a time when many families are struggling to keep their heads above water. By modestly expanding the sales tax base, we will be able to reduce the top income tax rate for all Mainers.
As a senior member of the BRED Committee, I am excited about the possibilities that the new tax law provides – this is an economic development tool. Maine is often called unfriendly to businesses. Our high income tax rate is often cited as proof of that claim. By lowering Maine’s income tax and capital gains rate by nearly 24 percent, we can help to put the “high tax” myth to rest while encouraging businesses to open in or move to Maine.
A lower top income tax rate means more money for Mainers. As an example, an elderly couple, taking the standard deduction, with an annual fixed income of $27,500, will see a total tax reduction of about $149. While $149 may not seem like a lot of money, when thousands of Maine families will be able to invest even $100 each year in Maine’s economy, we will see growth. This example comes from real tax returns. Those of us who worked on this tax reform package worked closely with Maine Revenue Services to include the most accurate estimates, so that we could provide the maximum benefit to the greatest number of Mainers.
Maine government is not making any money off of this tax reform. Unlike other states, this plan is not about bringing more revenue into the state coffers. This plan is about putting more money into Mainers’ pockets and changing Maine’s perceived status as a high-tax state. This plan brings Maine’s tax code into the 21st century and broadens and diversifies the sales tax base.
We have the added benefit of shifting a good portion of the tax burden to out-of-staters and non-residents, and asking them to pay their fair share. I want to make clear that the proposed increase to the meals and lodging tax is modest enough to keep Maine far below most destination locations and the New England average. Maine will continue to have the lowest lodging tax is New England, and one of the lowest meals taxes. In addition, the final version of the law puts an additional $3 million each year into tourism promotion for our state. If you are still feeling on edge about losing visitors to our state, I would point out that Vermont saw no impact when it raised its rate to 9 percent a few years ago. This year, New Hampshire did the same; and the state is keeping all of that revenue while Maine is giving their revenues back through lower income taxes.
This law has been praised at the state and national levels for its fiscal responsibility, and opponents of the plan should be asked to explain why they are interested in keeping Maine’s top income tax rate the sixth highest in the nation and delaying $57 million in reduced tax burden to Mainers. It is time to implement this economic development tool and offer Mainers the relief they need.






