The Star-Herald

Presque Isle Criminal Docket, August 2021

PRESQUE ISLE, Maine — The following cases were heard under the Aroostook Criminal Docket at the Presque Isle Courthouse in August.

Rodney E. York Jr., 46, Presque Isle: operating after habitual offender revocation, dismissed.

Joseph A. Donnelly, 50, Caribou: domestic violence assault, 364 days in prison, all but 14 days suspended, two years probation; domestic violence criminal threatening, 48 hours in jail.

Jefferey W. Nickerson, 59, Presque Isle: operating under the influence (alcohol), $500 fine, seven days in jail, license suspended 150 days, registration suspended; operating vehicle without license – conditions/restrictions, 48 hours in jail.

Jeffrey L. Lausier, 54, Presque Isle: violating condition of release, 60 days in jail, $750 restitution; aggravated furnishing of scheduled drugs, 12 months in prison; aggravated trafficking of scheduled drugs, dismissed; illegal possession of firearm, dismissed; criminal forfeiture of property, forfeiture.

Beau R. Everett, 69, Caribou: OUI (alcohol), prior, $700 fine, seven days in jail, license suspended three years.

Perry Paul, 69, Presque Isle: OUI (alcohol), dismissed; driving to endanger, dismissed.

Scott C. Correll, 55, Portage: assault, dismissed; disorderly conduct, offensive words, gestures, $300 fine.

Christopher J. Coty, 41, Caribou: operating after habitual offender revocation, priors, $1,000 fine, all suspended, one year in prison.  

Tonya L. Rasmussen, 47, Fort Fairfield: unlawful trafficking in scheduled drugs, $400 fine, two years in prison, all suspended, two years probation.

Donna E. Johnson, 25, New Vineyard: theft by unauthorized taking or transfer (two counts), $200 fine, $36.64 restitution (first), $200 fine (second); unlawful possession of scheduled drug, $400 fine.

Alexander J. Medina, 51, Presque Isle: OUI (alcohol), $500 fine, seven days in jail, license suspended one year and 60 days; operating vehicle without license, 48 hours in jail.

Travis Styles, 32, Mapleton: probation violation,16 months in prison, probation revoked.

Shelby L. York, 30, Presque Isle: robbery, dismissed; hindering apprehension or prosecution, dismissed.

Ronald D. Argraves, 72, Castle Hill: shooting from motor vehicle, $300 fine; criminal trespass, dismissed.

Ares Joseph Rattray, 33, Presque Isle, aggravated trafficking of schedule W drug, dismissed; violating condition of release (three counts), six months in jail (each); unlawful possession of scheduled drug, dismissed; criminal forfeiture of property (two counts), forfeiture (each); unlawful trafficking in scheduled drugs, $400 fine, 30 months in prison, $120 restitution.

John McNally, 52, Presque Isle: unlawful trafficking in scheduled drugs, dismissed.

Stephen Larson, 52, Caribou: robbery, dismissed; burglary, dismissed; criminal threatening with dangerous weapon, dismissed; criminal threatening, 10 months in prison.

Renee J. Markee, 55, Wade: OUI (alcohol), $500 fine, license suspended 150 days; operating vehicle without a license, $250 fine.

Jeffrey A. Nickerson, 59, Presque Isle: operating while license suspended or revoked – OUI, $600 fine, 10 days in jail, license suspended one year, registration suspended; operating vehicle without license – conditions/restrictions, 48 hours in jail; violating condition of release, seven days in jail.

Jeffrey T. Hardgrove, 44, Presque Isle: domestic violence assault, dismissed.

Kirk A. Tompkins, 47, Fort Fairfield: probation violation, six months in jail, probation partially revoked.

Nicole J. Gohar, 46, Presque Isle: operating while license suspended or revoked, dismissed.

Andrea E. Fitzherbert, 31, Presque Isle: disorderly conduct, loud unreasonable noise, dismissed; theft by receiving stolen property, $250 fine.

Jonathan L. Henderson, 22, Presque Isle: gross sexual assault, dismissed; furnishing liquor to a minor, $250 fine, six months in jail.

Larry W. Carll, 43, Linneus: unlawful possession of scheduled drug, $400 fine, seven days in jail, restitution $120; violating condition of release (two counts), no sentence listed (first), dismissed (second). 

Ariel L. Rosado Jr., 22, Caribou: operating after habitual offender revocation, $500 fine, 30 days in Jail.

Nicole J. Gohar, 46, Presque Isle: operating while license suspended or revoked, dismissed.

Andrea Fitzherbert, 31, Presque Isle: operating while license suspended or revoked, dismissed; violating condition of release, dismissed.

Robert Wright, 56, Presque Isle: criminal threatening, dismissed; criminal mischief, dismissed.

Keith R. Nott, 63, Wilder, Vermont: acting as guide without license, acquitted.

Robert Grosser, 41, Woodland: attaching false plates, 48 hours in jail; operating while license suspended or revoked, prior, $500 fine; violating condition of release (two counts) 48 hours in jail (each).

Michael McNutt, 67, New Limerick: hunting under the influence over 21, $400 fine.

Andrea Fitzherbert, 31, Presque Isle: burglary, dismissed; theft by unauthorized taking or transfer, dismissed; violating condition of release, $100 fine; criminal trespass, $300 fine.

Miranda A. Burby, 34 , Ashland: theft by unauthorized taking or transfer, $500 fine, $731.72 restitution.

Debora L. Brewer, 63, Monticello: stalking – serious inconvenience/emotional distress, $500 fine.

Matthew A. Phillips, 24, Presque Isle: operating vehicle without license $100 fine.

Vivian M. Silvia, 38, Frenchville: unlawful possession of scheduled drug, $400 fine, $120 restitution; possession of hypodermic apparatuses, $500 fine. 

Elizabeth C. Shumway, 27, Caribou: violating condition of release, $250 fine.

Cole Farley, 25, Mapleton: attaching false plates, $200 fine.

Clifton Leager, 39, Ashland: driving to endanger, $575 fine, license suspended 30 days.

Amanda M. Cole, 30, Presque Isle: operating while license suspended or revoked, prior, $500 fine; violating condition of release, $100 fine.

Jamie L. Fitzherbert, 39, Essex Junction Vermont: aggravated criminal mischief, dismissed.

Emily Sue Dubay, 39, Presque Isle: attaching false plates, dismissed.

Robert M. Gardner, 28, Ashland: operating while license suspended or revoked, prior, $500 fine.

Joshua Lee St. Peter, 41, Caribou: violating condition of release, $500 fine.

Stenson J. Gustin, 24, Caribou: theft by unauthorized taking or transfer, dismissed; aggravated criminal mischief, dismissed.

Warren W. Sirois, 81, Presque Isle: theft by unauthorized taking or transfer, $100 fine.

Asa Cook, 38, Bridgewater: failing to notify of motor vehicle accident, $500 fine.

Jordan Leager, 24, Ashland: criminal mischief, dismissed.

Steven M Berthiaume, 41, Limestone: theft by unauthorized taking or transfer, dismissed.

Mark Ouellette, 60, Terryville, Connecticut: possessing fish in violation, $100 fine.

Nicholas Foster, 34, Ellsworth: operating ATV on public way, $100 fine.

Douglas Clifford, 58, Fort Fairfield: violating fishing rule, $100 fine.

Jonathan D. Oliver, 38, Monticello: failing to produce permit, $150 fine.

Get the Rest of the Story

Thank you for reading your 4 free articles this month. To continue reading, and support local, rural journalism, please subscribe.