Wind ordinance remains up in the air

17 years ago

    “A lot of the stipulations in here pretty much eliminate these (wind turbines) being put anywhere in a residential area.”
Councilor Jennifer Trombley

By Kathy McCarty  
Staff Writer

   PRESQUE ISLE, Maine — City Council held the first of two public hearings on an amendment to a city ordinance addressing the use of wind turbines in residential areas.

    At their July 6 session, councilors considered amending Chapter 16 of the Land Use and Development Code ordinance to add in Chapter II, Section VIII, Small Wind Energy Systems, and Chapter I, Section V, definitions. If implemented, the change could have an impact on residential wind turbine construction as well as
Mike Cyr, of Presque Isle, was the only citizen to speak on the matter. He expressed concern regarding the recommendations made by the Presque Isle Planning Board. Section VIII stated, “On parcels greater than five contiguous acres in area, small wind energy systems (SWES) will require setbacks of not less than 4.0 times the heights of the blades and shall not exceed a maximum height recommended by the manufacturer or distributor of the SWES model used.”
Cyr questioned why it would be done that way and why it would not require the same setback requirements with two contiguous acres. He also wanted to know why there is a limit to 5 kw under Section E – 2 Power Generation.
Also questioned was Section F’s application for requirements that required tower foundation blueprints or drawings to be completed or reviewed and stamped by a Maine licenses professional engineer, with seal. Cyr asked if this was common practice in all building plans and said there was no indication that a national standard must be followed.
“Is that common practice on all building plans?” Cyr asked.
Ken Arndt, the city’s planning and development director, said the engineer requirement was derived from a model ordinance. He said this first hearing was designed to take comments and have answers prior to the next hearing prior to any subsequent decisions being made. Arndt said he’d reviewed ordinances for over a dozen communities, with this version being based on one generated by Biddeford.
“Whether further modifications need to be made will be determined by comments received,” said Arndt.
Councilor G. Melvin Hovey asked if the regulations, as written, prevent SAD 1 from developing their proposed wind projects.
Arndt indicated there might be an issue with SAD 1’s high school property and near the airport (middle school).
“I suspect right now that it (revised ordinance) would not allow for optimization of towers but (SAD 1) could put something that would generate power,” said Arndt, noting air space limitations could further limit development.
Councilor Jennifer Trombley saw the amendment as, “more prohibiting than regulating” in nature.
“A lot of the stipulations in here pretty much eliminate these (wind turbines) being put anywhere in a residential area,” said Trombley.
Councilor Walt Elish asked if the ordinance had been in place as revised if the University of Maine at Presque Isle’s wind turbine would have been approved.
“I doubt they (UMPI) would have the fall/safety zone. They probably would not be able to put one up under this ordinance,” said Arndt.
Under the ordinance, the city would be able to regulate small wind generation systems, with the FAA regulating larger units like those installed in Mars Hill and UMPI and proposed by Northern Maine Community College and SAD 1, said Arndt.
Trombley expressed her discomfort with the ordinance and said she needed more understanding of it in order to make an informed decision.
Arndt suggested councilors meet in a workshop atmosphere to gain a better understanding of the proposed ordinance.
Council Chair Ed Nickerson stated comments/questions should be director to Arndt and that Cyr meet with Arndt to share his specific concerns prior to the next hearing on Aug. 3.
If approved, the ordinance would limit the placement of wind turbines in residential areas, based on acreage and would address safety concerns, should the structure collapse or a mechanical problem arise.
Council will continue discussion of the matter at their August 3 meeting at 6 p.m. at City Hall. For more information, contact 764-4485.